<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=159418561124433&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
Blueprint-header.jpg

How to Choose a Contractor for Your Home Renovation

Tilghman Builders Team
By Tilghman Builders Team - January 25, 2024

Embarking on a home renovation journey is an exciting venture, and selecting the right contractor is key to the success of your project. As a trusted home renovation company in the heart of Pennsylvania, we understand the significance of this decision.

In this blog, we share invaluable insights and expert tips to guide you through the process. With decades of experience transforming homes across the state, we're here to empower you with the knowledge needed to make informed decisions, ensuring your renovation experience is not only seamless but also brings your vision to life.

The Importance of Choosing the Right Contractor

Having a contractor, landscaper, pest control worker, or really anyone working in your home is an inconvenience — and, to put it simply, annoying.

If you’re considering renovating your home and undergoing a medium- to large-scale project, be warned: You don’t want to pick just anyone to be in your home every day for weeks or months.

When a contractor isn’t the right fit, you may experience:

  • Frustration and resentment toward the person with whom you’ll need to continue talking, planning, and scheduling to finish the project

  • Resentment toward your spouse who really wanted to go with this contractor over another

  • Inconveniences like disrupted routines, getting your car blocked in, things left out of place, or doors left open

  • Excessive dust

  • Excessive noise

  • Overall disappointment and buyer’s remorse

7 Key Considerations When Shopping for a Contractor

When shopping for a contractor, it's crucial to consider these seven key factors.

How to Choose a Contractor for Your Home Renovation

1. Assess Their Online Presence

When beginning your contractor search, start by assessing their online presence. Dive into customer reviews, providing valuable insights into the contractor's performance.

Beyond reviews, explore the "About Us" page on their website. A transparent and detailed page showcasing their team is indicative of a well-established and organized contractor. If the team isn't featured, it could signal a lack of stability or frequent turnover, raising potential concerns about project consistency and reliability.

Don't forget to check their social media platforms for additional glimpses into their work and client interactions.

2. Ask for References

One of the most crucial steps is asking for references. A reputable contractor should willingly provide an extensive list of prior clients.

While some contractors might cherry-pick only their favorites, a diverse selection that includes ongoing projects provides a more accurate picture. Contacting clients currently undergoing renovations offers the most relevant insights into the contractor's current practices, communication, and project management.

3. Don’t Pick the Cheapest Contractor

While budget considerations are essential, be cautious about choosing the cheapest contractor solely based on initial proposals. Clear, detailed, and thorough proposals should be the priority. 

Some contractors may present lower prices initially but compensate with numerous change orders during the project. Opting for a more expensive contractor with a well-organized proposal may save you from unexpected costs and regrets down the line.

4. Watch Out for the One-Man Band

Consider the implications of hiring a one-man band — an owner-operator working solo. Although their prices may be enticing due to lower overheads, be aware of potential drawbacks. 

One-man bands often wear multiple hats, leading to project delays as they juggle meetings, estimates, and site work. Issues such as accounting irregularities and the need for deposits before completing projects can arise, emphasizing the importance of thorough consideration.

5. Inquire About Subcontractor Involvement

Understanding the extent of subcontractor involvement is crucial. While subcontractors play a vital role — you wouldn’t want a carpenter running all of your electrical or taking forever on your drywall and spackle — a company that subcontracts all tasks may result in a messy and unpredictable process.

Ideally, a contractor should handle carpentry work in-house, ensuring more control over schedules and minimizing disruptions to your project's timeline.

6. Verify Their Years in Business

There’s a 90% chance of going out of business in the first five years of operation for any business owner. You wouldn’t want this to happen to your contractor while on your project.

Consider the contractor's longevity in the industry. Opt for a contractor with an established track record to reduce the risk of project disruptions. A well-established business signifies stability, reliability, and a wealth of experience.

7. Who Will Be in Your Home Every Day?

While you may have positive interactions with the salesperson or owner, it's essential to know the background, skills, and reliability of the individuals performing the daily work. Consider the following questions:

  • Will they communicate?

  • Will they show up when you expect them to?

  • Will they be considerate of your home and its possessions?

Also, inquire about background checks and drug screenings to ensure a seamless, trustworthy, and considerate renovation experience. Effective communication and reliability are key attributes to look for in the daily workers who will bring your renovation project to life.

Making Informed Choices for Your Home Renovation

Choosing a contractor is an important decision that extends beyond budget considerations. It involves evaluating the contractor's reliability, transparency, and overall approach to your unique project.

By thoroughly exploring these considerations, you’re not only safeguarding your investment but also setting the foundation for a positive renovation experience. Your dream home is a collaborative creation, and with the right contractor, every detail becomes a reflection of your unique style and aspirations.

Homeowners in Bucks and Montgomery Counties trust Tilghman Builders for our commitment to quality craftsmanship, client satisfaction, and meticulous project management. With a longstanding reputation for honesty, accountability, and kindness, we’d be thrilled to help turn your dream home into a reality. Reach out to our team now to get started.